Energy Taxation Directive: Identifying the appropriate legal basis

Energy Taxation Directive: Identifying the appropriate legal basis

This short memo deals with the legal basis that the EU can rely upon in the revision of the Energy Taxation Directive (ETD).

It will first discuss two cases of the CJEU (C-626/18 & C-482/17) that have dealt with the question of the applicable legal basis within the context of the revision of EU directives.

It will then proceed to outline the legal reasoning to rely on in order to promote the adoption of the ordinary legislative procedure in the revision of the ETD. As assessed in details below, we believe that:

– Both cases C-626/18 & C-482/17 resulted in negative outcomes for the applicants and confirmed the consistency in EU case law in relation to the legal basis of EU measures.

– A legal basis can be found in both article 192(1) and (3) TFEU. However, the most compelling argument would find its base in article 192(1) TFEU, according to which the revision of the ETD is predominantly inspired by environmental concerns and as a consequence, the ordinary legislative procedure should be applied as the environmental objectives listed in article 191 TFEU are being pursued.

Download: Energy Taxation Directive Legal Basis Opinion

Share this article

Don’t Stop Here

More To Explore

Fishing boats in the village Union Hall, West Cork, Ireland. Union Hall is synonymous with fresh fish. Photo: davewalshphoto.com

Decarbonise Now Response to Belgium’s Undermining of EU Energy Taxation Directive

“The question is, why do EU finance ministers under the lead of the Belgian Presidency seem unable to make the decision to move away from fossil fuel subsidies towards other types of tax benefits, or other subsidies that would incentivise the decarbonization process of the fisheries or maritime transport sectors, and would lead to a much-needed carbon-free EU economy?”

Fishing boats in the harbour of Saint Jean de Luz, Basque Country, Pyrenees Atlantiques, France. Photo: davewalshphoto.com

Briefing: Is the urgency of eliminating fossil fuel subsidies for fisheries reflected in the Energy Taxation Directive?

Without the elimination of fossil fuel subsidies from our economies, it will be impossible to reach the agreed climate targets at global level and ensure a decent future for the planet and humankind in the next decades. The recent COP28 climate summit recognised the need to transition away from fossil fuels, and the phasing out inefficient fossil fuel subsidies that do not address energy poverty or just transitions, as soon as possible.

Fishing boat - fishing for lobster and crab near the Ile de Batz, Brittany, France. Photo: davewalshphoto.com

Briefing: Financing the Decarbonisation of the EU Fisheries Sector

We are in the midst of a climate crisis, with the effects of rising temperatures – due to climate change – now making themselves known everywhere. At the same time, we are facing a major biodiversity crisis, which hugely impacts the marine environment and the functioning of the ocean as a climate regulator. On top of these major crises, with the ongoing war in Ukraine, we also face an unprecedented energy challenge.